The New Heroic Age | The State of the Genre: Why 0% of Amazon’s Top 10 are Actually Not Superhero Stories.

The Amazon Top 10 “Superhero” list is a mess. It’s time to clean it out.

I took a look at the rankings today, March 14, and if you’re looking for a true superhero story—the kind built on inescapable obligation and the clear-cut battle between Good and Evil—you won’t find it there. What you’ll find is a pile of “Pretenders” wearing the genre like a cheap costume.

According to the Doctrine of Superhero Fiction, the current Top 10 is batting zero. Here is the breakdown of why the industry has lost its way:

1. Having “Stats” Doesn’t Make You a Hero

The list is currently dominated by titles like The Hunter’s Code and The Last Paladin. These are LitRPG and “Progression Fantasy.” People like seeing numbers go up and characters “leveling up,” but a superhero isn’t a character sheet. In the New Heroic Age, power isn’t a prize you win; it’s a responsibility you’re stuck with. If the main goal is just getting stronger, it’s a game, not a hero’s journey.

2. It’s a Calling, Not a Nine-to-Five

Then you have the “procedurals” like Threat Level: IceStorm. This is a fine thriller, but if you’re wearing a badge and collecting a government pension, you’re an employee. A superhero operates on a level of moral duty that doesn’t wait for a supervisor’s approval. When you turn “the hero’s burden” into a job description, you lose the soul of the genre.

3. Enough with the “Edgy” Ambiguity

Then there’s Vicious. It’s a bestseller, and it’s the poster child for what I hate: “No one is a hero, everyone is a monster.” I’ve said it before: Moral ambiguity sucks. If I wanted to read about two terrible people being terrible to each other, I’d read the news. True superhero fiction requires the courage to say that some things are Right and some things are Wrong.

4. Satire is Just a Polite Way of Mocking Us

From Starter Villain to various “Romantasy” titles, we’re seeing the genre treated as a joke or a “meet-cute” gimmick. When you spend the whole book winking at the camera and mocking the tropes of the genre, you aren’t honoring it. You’re just using the label to sell a comedy.

---

The Bottom Line

The Amazon Top 10 isn’t a list of superhero books; it’s a list of books about people with powers who would rather be doing literally anything else. We’ve traded Inescapable Obligation for “relatable” Slackers, Stat-Chasers, and Satirists.

It’s exactly why I’m building the EVOREALM. We need prose that respects the mantle. We need the hero who stands up because he must, not because he’s getting paid or “leveling up.”

The deconstruction ends here. Welcome to the New Heroic Age.

Rank	Title	Status	Doctrine Assessment
1	The Hunter’s Code	Pretender	This is Progression Fantasy/LitRPG. The focus is on leveling up and personal power growth, not a moral duty to the public. It’s a “gamified” power fantasy.
2	The Last Paladin	Pretender	Also Progression Fantasy. While “Paladin” implies a code, these stories almost always prioritize the protagonist’s survival and “stat” increases over an inescapable moral obligation.
3	Delivering Justice 2	Pretender	This is part of a “Men’s Adventure” series, which is usually code for “Harem” or “Gamelit” with a focus on romantic/physical conquests rather than the weight of the hero’s mantle.
4	Nevermore (Echoes)	Pretender	Dystopian Sci-Fi/Military Thriller. It follows an “Enforcer” in a futuristic regime. It lacks the clear “Good vs. Evil” clarity, focusing instead on political rebellion.
5	Threat Level: IceStorm	Pretender	Urban Fantasy. It’s about an “FBI Magical Threats Division.” Under your Doctrine, if the hero is just doing a job (government employee), it’s a procedural, not a superhero story.
6	Starter Villain	Pretender	Satire/Deconstruction. John Scalzi writes with heavy irony. It mocks the tropes you respect and centers on a villainous inheritance rather than a hero’s duty.
7	Vicious	Pretender	Moral Ambiguity. This is the “poster child” for what you dislike. V.E. Schwab explicitly stated there are no heroes in this book—just two monsters clashing.
8	Delivering Justice 1	Pretender	(See Book 3). Another entry in the “Men’s Adventure” sub-genre. It prioritizes the “male fantasy” tropes over the inescapable burden of the superhero.
9	I Dated the Mind’s Eye	Pretender	Romance/Romantasy. It uses superhero powers as a “meet-cute” or a dating obstacle. It treats powers as a quirk, not a moral cross to bear.
10	Rival.EXE	Pretender	LitRPG/Satire. The protagonist is the son of a villain and a hero who is “forced” into roles by a “System.” Your Doctrine requires choice-less duty, not a computer-generated path.